EDITORIALS
Five Ways Your Ad Agency Will Work In 2011
On the morning of November 17 I got a brief that asked me to write a post titled "Five Ways Your Ad Agency Will Work In 2011" for the Karsh\Hagan blog. And that afternoon, I saw this in Fast Company:
Over the past few years, because of a combination of Internet disintermediation, recession, and corporate blindness, the [advertising] assembly line has been obliterated -- economically, organizationally, and culturally. In the ad business, the relatively good life of 2007 is as remote as the whiskey highs of 1962.
Ouch.
I wasn't surprised by Fast Company's doom and gloom. The article was just a retread of all the Big Scary Death of Advertising stories we've been reading for a few years now. But being boring doesn't make you wrong. The world of 2011 looks nothing like the one in which many of us learned our craft.
In a 2008 interview I did with Scott Goodson on FutureLab, I said the greatest challenge for the marcomm industry was this:
Defining for new clients how we will approach their business problems.
I still think that's true. But while the pitch process remains a bit of a jumble, the agency business model has changed. In 2011, your ad agency will be faster and more innovative than ever before. Here are five reasons why.
1. Collaboration: Today, culture is made with mash-ups. It's about Kid Cudi mixing Christian Bale with LCD Soundsystem. About ideas that build on each other. That's how agencies will be working in 2011. Small teams of people coming together to add fresh thinking to existing work.
2. Content: Social media is great. But brands shouldn't jump into other folks' conversations uninvited. They should start by creating content worthy of conversation. And then listen, engage and refine.
3. Play: Ty Montague. Kevin Roddy. Alex Bogusky. Those are three of the biggest names in advertising and in 2010 they all quit their fabulous network jobs to explore the great unknown. Experimentation, play and the freedom to fail. Those are the seeds of creativity and the path to the biggest ideas.
4. Flexibility: To a man with a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. And to an agency with a bunch of specialists with billable hours to fill, every problem looks like it requires the attention of a bunch of specialists with billable hours to fill. To combat this agencies will hire people who have flexible skill sets and similar visions.
5. Platforms: There are fun individual executions. There are powerful integrated campaigns. And then there are flexible, infinite platforms. For instance, Karsh\Hagan's 100 Honest Answers campaign for American Crew has run its course. But the Ask American Crew platform we built underneath it will always be there if they want to use it again. Your agency should be thinking about the long, long run.
If the brief I'd gotten had asked for a sixth opportunity, I would add happiness to this list, and define it as "a blissful childlike state resulting from the act of creation." Because I think ad agencies are much less tied to the 30-second spot than the media would have you believe. There is so much cool stuff yet to be made. And as long as we're making it, we'll be so, so happy. Suck on that, Fast Company.
[Ed. - This post was written by Karsh\Hagan's Matt Ingwalson and cross-posted on his blog and Karsh Connect.]


Comments
i feel like i have been reading the same article for 2 years. i like the path of the idea and building the brand platform, but i have a question, specifically to matt:
how do you get unknowing clients to agree to building the brand platform? how do you get client who see quarters and maybe a year in advance?
i have found it so hard to speak to a client in a 3-5 year margin. they always seem to want results now.
is there a certain size of client this plays to better than another? does this plan work well with a 3 person clothing company and a 60 person beverage company?
maybe it is my inexperience in the industry, i guess i see a lot of talk about future planning followed by a lot of direct mailers and banner ads.
in summary how do you get clients to see the overall idea of this 5 step plan? its a great plan, safely vague yet moldable.
i realize this may be a loaded question, i am just an interested creative.
Jordan, this is the second time I've had a post appear on the Egotist and wished I'd had a single word back after publishing it. I think a better title would have been, "Five Ways Your Ad Agency Should Work," instead of "Five Ways Your Ad Agency Will Work." I live and learn.
I think your comment, "i have found it so hard to speak to a client in a 3-5 year margin. they always seem to want results now," is insightful. My initial reaction was to point you to K\H's How To Sell Our Creative Ideas. But maybe a whole new post is in order. I'm kind of psyched to try to write something that addresses the topics you raised.
Good read. Thanks, Matt.
i remember that poster, i put it up on the k/h blog way back in the summer of ought-nine.
my only thing is:
i got a lot of experience being the second man in a two man crew with meyer. and when finding new clients who need a whole new brand. their logo was done be a nephew and their site was done by some student. trying to explain to them how everything should connect. building their brand. it seems your exposition is written for an agency who can dedicate three or more creatives solely to one brand. what about the 3-5 man shops that have 3 little clients.
i am excited to read your follow up addressing these issues. because size of the client is a huge factor. if you are dealing with the owner vs someone he hired specifically for marketing or working through an account person etc...
tell lindsay j i think she's hot,
jordan
Amen on #2. Some research conducted by MarketingProfs and Junta42 suggests that content marketing budgets are poised to grow by approx. 25%. Huge.
The future of advertising? http://bit.ly/h3gmJ7
Post new comment